Table of Contents ▼
- I. What is a Lombard loan? Definition and origins
- II. The legal framework for pledging securities accounts
- III. How is the pledge constituted?
- IV. The scope of the pledge: which assets are covered?
- V. LTV, advance ratios and eligible assets
- VI. How the loan works: rates, duration and repayment
- VII. The major risk: margin calls
- VIII. Enforcement of the pledge in the event of default
- IX. The bank’s obligations: information and duty to warn
- X. Bank liability and borrower’s duty of good faith
- XI. Wealth management and tax strategies
- XII. The Lombard loan in LBO transactions
- XIII. Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
- XIV. Conclusion
I. What is a Lombard loan? Definition and origins
Historical origins
The term “Lombard loan” originates from the Italian region of Lombardy, where, as early as the Middle Ages, Lombard bankers granted loans against the delivery of assets as collateral. This ancient mechanism has endured through the centuries to become one of the most sophisticated financing tools in modern banking law.
Legal definition
Under French banking law, the Lombard loan refers to a loan granted by a credit institution, secured by the pledge of a securities portfolio (securities account, PEA, life insurance or securities registered on a blockchain). The debtor retains management of their portfolio but assigns it as security for the repayment of the loan.
In terms of security interests, this constitutes a pledge over intangible movable property: the securities account is an intangible asset over which a real security right is established in favour of the creditor — in this case, the bank.
• Purpose-specific loan
• Collateral = financed asset
• Non-purpose loan (free use)
• Collateral = pledged portfolio
With a Lombard loan, they pledge their shares and borrow €200,000 (advance ratio of 50%). They retain their €400,000 invested, pay no capital gains tax, and fund their project with the borrowed funds. If their shares continue to appreciate, they benefit on both fronts.
II. The legal framework for pledging securities accounts
The fundamental provisions
The legislative foundation rests on Article L. 211-20 of the Monetary and Financial Code (Code monétaire et financier), supplemented by regulatory articles D. 211-10 to D. 211-14-1 of the same code. These provisions govern the constitution, enforceability, scope and enforcement of the pledge.
Ordonnance No. 2021-1192 of 15 September 2021 modernised this regime to integrate securities registered in a shared electronic recording device (DEEP / blockchain). Ordonnance No. 2024-936 of 15 October 2024 further adapted this framework.
III. How is the pledge constituted?
The principle: the pledge declaration
The constitution mechanism is remarkable for its formal simplicity. Unlike the general regime under Article 2356 of the Civil Code, no notarial deed or separate private instrument is required.
Article L. 211-20, I of the CMF provides that the pledge is constituted, both between the parties and with respect to the issuer and third parties, by a simple declaration signed by the account holder, provided it contains the mandatory particulars.
The Cour de cassation has confirmed this principle on several occasions: only the pledge declaration is necessary for the pledge to be established and enforceable (Cass. com., 20 June 2018, No. 17-12.559; Cass. com., 23 Jan. 2019, No. 16-20.582; Cass. com., 30 Nov. 2022, No. 20-23.554).
Mandatory particulars (Article D. 211-10 CMF)
The declaration must be dated and signed by the pledgor and must imperatively contain:
- The exact designation of the instrument.
- A statement that the declaration is subject to the provisions of Article L. 211-20 of the CMF.
- The full identity of the pledgor and the secured creditor.
- The amount of the secured claim or the elements enabling its identification.
- The identifying details of the special account (pledged account).
- The type and number of financial securities initially registered.
Enforceability: no mandatory notification
The declaration alone suffices to render the pledge enforceable. There is no need to notify the issuing company (Cass. com., 20 June 2018, No. 17-12.559) or the account keeper, “notwithstanding any clause to the contrary” (Cass. com., 30 Nov. 2022, No. 20-23.554).
The supplementary agreement in practice
Practitioners systematically draft a separate pledge agreement to specify the particular conditions: financial covenants, minimum coverage ratios, obligation to reconstitute the pledge base, terms for managing the pledged securities, etc.
IV. The scope of the pledge: which assets are covered?
One of the major advantages of the Lombard loan lies in the evolving nature of the pledge scope.
Initial securities and subsequent securities
Under Article L. 211-20, I of the CMF, financial securities and, unless otherwise agreed, amounts subsequently credited to the pledged account are deemed to have been delivered on the date of the declaration. In practical terms:
- The securities initially registered in the account.
- Securities that are added to or substituted for them (merger, exchange, conversion).
- Income and proceeds (dividends, interest) credited to the pledged account or a dedicated account.
The “income and proceeds” account
Since 1 January 2022, the regime clearly distinguishes between the constitution of the security interest and the allocation of income and proceeds (Articles L. 211-20, III and R. 211-14-1 CMF).
V. LTV, advance ratios and eligible assets
The LTV concept (Loan to Value)
The amount that can be borrowed depends on the LTV ratio (Loan to Value), i.e. the ratio between the loan amount and the value of the assets provided as collateral. The safer and more liquid the assets, the higher the ratio.
Advance ratios by asset class
• Government bonds (LTV 95%) → available borrowing of €475,000
• Euro-denominated funds (LTV 85%) → available borrowing of €425,000
• Blue-chip equities such as LVMH (LTV 75%) → available borrowing of €375,000
• Diversified ETFs (LTV 60%) → available borrowing of €300,000
• Cryptocurrencies via Luxembourg life insurance (LTV 40%) → available borrowing of €200,000
The choice of pledged asset class therefore directly impacts the available leverage.
VI. How the loan works: rates, duration and repayment
The most common arrangement is the bullet loan (prêt in fine): the borrower only pays interest and repays the full principal at maturity. If the portfolio generates an 8% annual return and the loan costs 3%, the borrower earns a net spread of 5% while avoiding capital gains taxation.
Simulation on a €200,000 bullet loan over 5 years:
• Annual interest: 200,000 × 3.54% = €7,080/year, i.e. approximately €590/month
• Total interest cost over 5 years: €35,400
• Principal repaid at maturity: €200,000
Meanwhile, if the pledged portfolio of €400,000 generates 8%/year:
• Annual gains: 400,000 × 8% = €32,000/year
• Cumulative gains over 5 years (compound interest): approximately €187,000
• Net result: 187,000 − 35,400 = +€151,600 in gains after deducting interest, without having paid any capital gains tax.
Rolling debt
At maturity, if the portfolio has appreciated in value, the borrower can take out a larger new loan to repay the previous one and generate additional liquidity. This is rolling debt (rollover), a technique widely used by high-net-worth individuals.
Year 5 (maturity): thanks to an 8%/year return, the portfolio is now worth approximately €735,000.
• New Lombard loan of €440,000 (LTV 60% on 735,000)
• Repayment of the previous loan: €300,000
• New liquidity generated: €140,000
• Tax: still €0 in capital gains
The portfolio has grown by €235,000, the borrower has generated €140,000 in additional liquidity, and no capital gains have been crystallised.
VII. The major risk: margin calls
The principal danger of a Lombard loan lies in the volatility of financial markets. If the value of the pledged portfolio falls, the LTV ratio deteriorates and the bank triggers a margin call (or top-up clause).
The two alert levels
The bank requests additional collateral or a partial repayment to restore the ratio.
The bank may liquidate the positions — sell the pledged securities to recover its capital.
Markets drop by 20%:
• Portfolio falls to €320,000
• New LTV ratio: 280,000 / 320,000 = 87.5% → Level 1 triggered
• The bank demands additional collateral of €80,000 in securities or cash, or a partial loan repayment.
Markets fall further (−35% from original level):
• Portfolio drops to €260,000
• New LTV ratio: 280,000 / 260,000 = 107% → Level 2 triggered
• The bank liquidates the positions and recovers €260,000
• The borrower has lost their entire portfolio and remains liable for €20,000 in residual debt (280,000 − 260,000).
Risk management best practices
- Maintain a significant safety margin by not borrowing the maximum authorised amount.
- Do not pledge your entire portfolio, in order to be able to respond to a margin call.
- Diversify the pledged portfolio to reduce overall volatility.
- Monitor coverage ratios regularly and anticipate market movements.
VIII. Enforcement of the pledge in the event of default
Conditions for enforcement
Article L. 211-20, V of the CMF strictly governs enforcement. Two cumulative conditions apply:
- A certain, liquid and due claim.
- A prior formal notice to the debtor (Cass. com., 18 Nov. 2008, No. 07-21.975).
Mandatory content of the formal notice
The formal notice must, on penalty of nullity, state that the pledge may be enforced within 8 days (or such other period as agreed), and that the pledgor may indicate the order of enforcement of the amounts or securities.
Procedure
For listed securities and units in collective investment schemes, enforcement takes place 8 days after the formal notice (Articles D. 211-11 to D. 211-13 CMF). The account keeper executes at the expense of the secured creditor.
IX. The bank’s obligations: information and duty to warn
The duty of information
The bank owes a duty of information regarding the characteristics of the loan and the specific risks associated with the pledge. However, it does not owe a general duty of advice, except in particular circumstances.
The duty to warn
Towards a non-sophisticated borrower, the bank must alert them to the risk of excessive indebtedness. This duty:
- Applies to bullet loans (Cass. com., 8 Nov. 2023, No. 22-13.750).
- Requires verification of suitability relative to assets and income (Cass. com., 9 Nov. 2022, No. 21-16.030).
- Must take into account foreseeable changes (retirement, etc.).
X. Bank liability and borrower’s duty of good faith
The borrower’s duty of good faith
The borrower must provide accurate information. In the event of a false declaration, contracts typically include an acceleration clause.
Limits of bank verification
The bank does not have a “policing” duty but must ensure the regularity and accuracy of documents and cannot ignore serious anomalies.
If the borrower has concealed their true financial position, they cannot invoke a failure to warn (Cass. 1re civ., 30 Oct. 2007, No. 06-17.003; Cass. com., 23 Sept. 2014, No. 13-20.874).
XI. Wealth management and tax strategies with the Lombard loan
The principle: enjoying your wealth without selling it
Benefiting from your investments without disposing of them, thereby avoiding immediate capital gains taxation (Flat Tax at 30% or progressive income tax scale). A loan is not taxable income — it is a liability, not income.
A company director wishes to fund €200,000 in personal expenses. They sell €200,000 worth of shares with €150,000 in unrealised gains.
• Flat Tax on capital gains: 150,000 × 30% = €45,000 in tax
• Net amount available: €155,000 — insufficient.
Scenario B — Lombard loan:
The same director pledges their €400,000 in shares and borrows €200,000 (LTV 50%).
• Capital gains tax: €0
• Loan cost (annual interest at ~3.5%): €7,000/year
• Amount available: €200,000 immediately, while retaining invested assets.
Immediate tax saving: €45,000. If their shares continue to generate 8% per year, they additionally earn €32,000/year on a portfolio they would otherwise have liquidated.
The leverage effect
Borrowing at 3.5% to invest in instruments yielding more (high-yield bonds, private equity). The yield differential constitutes the net gain.
• Income generated: 200,000 × 8% = €16,000/year
• Loan cost: 200,000 × 3.5% = €7,000/year
• Net leverage gain: €9,000/year (4.5% spread)
This gain is in addition to the performance of the original portfolio. However, if the investments underperform relative to the loan cost, the leverage effect works in reverse.
The Holding Company + Lombard Loan + SCI structure
Without a Lombard loan:
To fund a lifestyle costing €100,000/year, they pay themselves a salary or dividends. Tax cost: between €30,000 and €55,000/year (Flat Tax 30%, or income tax + social contributions).
With a Lombard loan:
• They pay themselves the statutory minimum wage (~€9,500/year) to cover social contributions and avoid the PUMa tax (supplementary healthcare contribution).
• They pledge part of their portfolio and borrow €100,000 to fund their lifestyle.
• Loan cost: 100,000 × 3.5% = €3,500/year
• Tax on loan proceeds: €0 (a loan is not taxable income)
Annual saving: between €26,000 and €51,000 depending on the alternative remuneration method. The wealth remains invested and continues to grow.
Instead of distributing these €300,000 to the director (which would trigger €90,000 in Flat Tax), the director:
• Takes out a Lombard loan of €150,000 secured against their personal portfolio
• Lends these €150,000 to their holding company via a shareholder current account remunerated at 4%
• Receives €6,000/year in interest, taxed at Flat Tax = €1,800 in tax
• The holding company deducts this interest from its taxable profit
Outcome: the director accesses liquidity, the holding company creates a deductible expense, and taxation drops from €90,000 to €1,800.
XII. The Lombard loan in LBO transactions
In LBO transactions, the shares of the acquired company held by the holding company constitute the principal assets pledged as security for the acquisition debt. The pledge scope automatically includes replacement securities and income and proceeds.
XIII. Frequently Asked Questions about the Lombard loan
What is the minimum amount required to obtain a Lombard loan?
Is the Lombard loan available to non-residents?
Can a PEA or life insurance policy be pledged?
What happens in the event of the borrower’s death?
Is the Lombard loan legal from a tax perspective?
What is the main risk of a Lombard loan?
XIV. Conclusion: should you use a Lombard loan?
The Lombard loan is a powerful wealth management tool that allows the mobilisation of liquidity without disposing of one’s investments. However, market volatility can transform a performance lever into a wealth-destroying trap.
As a banking law attorney, I recommend that any investor considering a Lombard loan:
- Have the pledge agreement and margin call clauses analysed by a legal professional.
- Ensure that the bank has satisfied its information and duty-to-warn obligations.
- Maintain a significant safety margin.
- Anticipate adverse market scenarios.
- Verify the compliance of the interest calculation applied by the lending institution.
Have you taken out a Lombard loan and are facing a dispute with your bank?
Failure to provide information, abusive margin call, irregular enforcement of the pledge — specialised legal assistance can make the difference.



